via We The Data
James Moore runs Independent Music Promotions, a DIY music PR company working exclusively with "music with depth" worldwide. He is the author of the Your Band Is A Virus book series.
This article originally appeared on Independent Music Promotions.
Almost every artist who approaches me has had one or more negative experiences with music promotion in the past, and this is largely due to the “quick fix syndrome” on behalf of both individuals who engage in the partnership.
First of all, there are the automated music marketing services who I tend to call the "internet cowboys." They offer progress and lavish promises at the push of a button. Facebook likes? You got it. YouTube views? Not a problem. Get your press release on the desks of thousands of journalists? They do that too.
The artists who tango with these folks also suffer from the quick fix syndrome. Rather than build a team of people and gain fans organically one by one, they instead aim for the mountaintop, neglecting to do the proper research or seek out the proof that Google can provide.
So what are some common warning signs to look out for when researching music promotion services? These aren't hard and fast rules, but they're all serious things to keep an eye on:
Not good, unless it’s a service such as bio writing that really does apply to every musician. This almost always means that their audience ignores their outreach. If there is no filtering whatsoever, it’s a virtual guarantee that the output is unprofessional. No quality control tends to mean no results. The service essentially has a welcoming face with no brain function.
For the same reason as above, this is usually a sign you should run for the hills – especially if these email blasts come with promises along the lines of sending you to X number of newspapers, magazines, journalists and music blogs. Find me a single story in a major publication that came about as the result of one of these kinds of email blasts. When was the last time you welcomed something that was “blasted” to your inbox? Marketing must be more organic than that.
This can get your profiles removed and it will certainly reduce your engagement to almost nothing. It also means that you’ll have to spend much more on advertising, because any genuine followers will be buried among all the fake profiles. Social media platforms are cracking down on this type of behavior.
They’re lying. Even when they say they do not use bots, they do. Youtube is also cracking down on this type of behavior, and I’ve seen over a dozen cases recently of music videos being taken down after months of hard work had been put into them – all because of the desire for a shortcut.
This is often emphasized to hide the fact that they are not driving real results where they matter, such as press, reviews, licensing deals, bookings, radio ads, and genuine, concrete opportunities. Anyone can post a status, blog a news release or tweet about you – you don’t need a company for that. Consulting and advice certainly have value, especially when it comes from knowledgeable people, but they are not worth thousands of dollars. And under no circumstance should you be taking advice from someone who doesn’t deliver results in the first place.
Client lists, generally, should be public (depending on the industry). Go beyond all the site rhetoric and let Google be your truth teller. Google one company’s artists versus another to see the real results that are being driven. If you only compare one site’s rhetoric with another, you’ll end up going with whoever promises the most (almost always a poor decision).
Promises, promises. The loftier the promises, the less likely they are to come through. Stay away. There’s no need for that kind of “dangling a carrot” form of communication unless they’re referring to hard work and a team effort. Real marketing is not a one-stop shop. It’s a real, living thing and it can’t be achieved with the push of a button.